19th Ave New York, NY 95822, USA

Study: Fast-Food Workers Rely On $7 Billion In Aid (Demo)

  • A report by UC Berkeley and the University of Illinois at Urbana-Champaign staffers comes on the heels of a fast-food staff walkout in August over low pay. Photo: Sam Wolson, Special To The Chronicle
    A report by UC Berkeley and the University of Illinois at Urbana-Champaign staffers comes on the heels of a fast-food staff walkout in August over low pay. Photo: Sam Wolson, Special To The Chronicle

On October 18, 2013, Stacy Finz writes in the SFGate:

The low wages paid to fast-food workers are costing taxpayers $7 billion a year in public assistance, according to a study released Tuesday by the UC Berkeley Labor Center.

Full-time workers at such places as McDonald’s and Burger King don’t make enough to support themselves, forcing them to enroll in welfare programs such as food stamps and Medicaid, the report shows. People working in fast-food jobs are more likely to live in or near poverty than any other job sector, with 43 percent having an income two times below the federal poverty level or less. In California alone, researchers estimate that low-paid fast-food workers are costing taxpayers $717 million a year in state and federal assistance.

The report, “Fast Food, Poverty Wages: The Public Cost of Low-Wage Jobs in the Fast Food Industry” was co-written with the University of Illinois at Urbana-Champaign’s department of urban and regional planning. The study’s release, and a companion report by the National Employment Law Project, comes after thousands of fast-food workers in 60 cities walked off their jobs in August, demanding higher pay. The study also comes at a time when Republicans in Congress are trying to cut government assistance such as food stamps.

Despite the perception that most employees at fast-food drive-throughs are high school and college kids, 26 percent are single and married adults with children, said Marc Doussard, one of the authors of the study.

Willietta Dukes, 40, has been working in fast-food restaurants since she was 26 years old. But she said she couldn’t have raised her two sons without welfare programs.

“Why should I have to rely on government assistance when I work as hard as anyone else?” Dukes, who earns $7.85 an hour at a Burger King in Durham, N.C., asked during a national press conference call. “Why shouldn’t I be paid what I’m worth? We’re the people making the restaurant.” She said there are times she has to forgo buying medicine because she can’t afford it.

The study found that 52 percent of the families of fast-food workers are enrolled in one or more public assistance programs, compared with 25 percent of the workforce as a whole. These families account for $3.9 billion a year in Medicaid and Children’s Health Insurance Program spending, and are receiving on average $1.04 billion in food stamp benefits, according to the researchers.

The Employment Policies Institute, a nonprofit group that argues that increasing the minimum wage increases unemployment for the non-educated and non-skilled, accused the researchers of being shills for labor unions.

“In its quest to unionize the fast food industry, the (Service Employees International Union) has demonstrated that it will leave no stone unturned, including using research and arguments that would get a higher grade in creative writing than in a high school economics class,” wrote Michael Saltsman, research director at the institute, in a press release.

The UC Berkeley authors of the study called the allegations “odd.”

“I’m an economist,” Sylvia Allegretto said. “This is what I do for a living.”

Devonte Yates, 21 and a McDonald’s worker in Milwaukee, doesn’t care what the motivation for the report is. All he knows is that he can’t make it on his $7.25-an-hour earnings.

“I rely on food stamps to eat at night,” he said. “The CEO of McDonald’s makes more in a day than I make in a year. We work hard, show up every day and are dedicated to these companies. Why shouldn’t we be paid a living wage?”

Sadly, this is the plight of a growing segment of the American population, solely dependent on low-pay hourly wage jobs and supplemental support government welfare, which costs taxpayer dollars and furthers our dependency on never-ending national debt.
At the same time the situation is ripping our nation apart with one segment of the population declaring “laziness” and opposing minimum wage laws, Food Stamp benefits and Medicaid expansion, and another segment promoting job dependency, government-dictated wage laws (not free market), and socialistic welfare support. Both see ONLY a job as a source of income for the majority of Americans and fail to recognize that job creation is not a viable long-term solution, and that the non-human factor of production resulting from technological invention and innovation makes many forms of labor unnecessary. Both also fail to see that the majority of Americans are being systematically denied equal opportunity to acquire private sector individual wealth-creating, income-generating productive capital property ownership on the same terms that the wealthy ownership class now utilizes in which the investment’s earnings pay off the capital credit loans used to finance their investments, without having to use their own money or deny themselves consumption. The unfortunate result is that the rich get richer through their continued concentration of productive capital ownership and the vast majority of Americans struggle with progressively less well-paid job opportunities, the devaluing of their worth as labors, and the prospects of falling into poverty and dependent on tax extraction from the productive sector and the continued incurrence of national debt to support supplemental welfare programs they require to make ends meet.
This should not be what America is about. Instead, our focus should be on OWNERSHIP CREATION in which employees of companies and other ordinary citizens OWN full-dividend paying and voting stock in the corporations they work for and patronize, and build over time a diversified portfolio of wealth-creating, income-generating stock assets that will provide them a second income beyond their reliance on a job. We need to reform the system to provide equal opportunity for EVERY American to become an OWNER, just like the wealthy ownership class, and significantly improve their long-term financial security. The focus needs to be on FUTURE sustainable production and broadening ownership. This will put us on a path to prosperity, opportunity, and economic justice and in the short-term significantly grow our economy with “full-employment” opportunities as EVERY American benefits from two sources of income.
As we build this FUTURE affluent economy, consumer confidence will be strengthened and businesses will benefit from an expanding population of “customers with money.” This will drive the demand for products and services the economy will be capable of producing, while achieving environmental renewability and sustainable viability. At the same time United States credibility and leadership around the world will be restored as our economy booms and we successfully alter the choices people must make between choosing alternative, more costly “greener” choices that do not threaten the environment and their very livelihood.
While this is not a “click-of-the-switch” solution, but long-term, in the short-term we must not fail those who require supplemental support. But we need to adopt a long-term solution that will eliminate and drastically reduce dependency on tax extraction and national debt and build a future responsibly sustainable economy that can support general affluence  for EVERY citizen and provide financial security into retirement.
See “Financing Economic Growth With ‘FUTURE SAVINGS’: Solutions To Protect America From Economic Decline” at NationOfChange.org http://www.nationofchange.org/financing-future-economic-growth-future-savings-solutions-protect-america-economic-decline-137450624, “The Income Solution To Slow Private Sector Job Growth” at http://www.nationofchange.org/income-solution-slow-private-sector-job-growth-1378041490, and “A Solution To Eroding Retirement Security” at http://www.huffingtonpost.com/gary-reber/a-solution-to-eroding-retirement_b_4103834.html and at http://www.nationofchange.org/solution-eroding-retirement-security-1382020223. Also see “Achieving The Green Economy” at http://www.nationofchange.org/achieving-green-economy-1373980790 and with complete footnotes with the footnotes at http://foreconomicjustice.org/?p=9082

Leave a comment